Here’s the latest I can summarize from recent reports:
A substantial cattle theft occurred in Mercer County, Ohio, with 64 Holstein calves reported missing from a farm near Coldwater. The timeframe was late on May 2 into the early hours of May 3, 2026. Authorities described the incident as highly coordinated, suggesting the perpetrators had cattle-handling experience. [sources indicate multiple outlets covering this event, including local and national aggregators][1][2][3][4][6][9][10]
The calves were roughly 13 weeks old, about 250 pounds each, and valued around $2,000 per head, placing the total loss in the six-figure range. Investigators stated they have not publicly identified any suspects as of the latest updates, and the investigation remains active.[3][5][1]
Local authorities and agricultural groups circulated descriptions and photos of the missing calves to auctions and livestock dealers in the region and neighboring states, in hopes of recovering the cattle or identifying leads. Rewards or tips may be available as the case progresses.[4][6]
Public interest and media coverage have highlighted the possibility of a black-market angle given the high value of cattle at the time, and investigators stressed the need for tips from anyone with information.[6]
Would you like me to:
COLDWATER, Ohio — Authorities are investigating a brazen overnight theft in which 64 young Holstein calves worth tens of thousands of dollars were stolen from a family farm operation near Coldwater in Mercer County.
www.ibtimes.com.au“Two different stages of cattle in that barn, again, which leads you to believe that somebody directly involved in this industry is involved somehow.”
www.kiro7.comMore than 60 Holstein calves were stolen from a Mercer County, Ohio farm. According to local news reports, the calves were stolen Monday night into early Tuesday morning near State Route 219 and Coldwater Creek Road. The cattle are owned by Gaerke Brother Farms and were raised by Selhorst Farms near Coldwater. In a statement to Brownfield, Sheriff […]
www.brownfieldagnews.comThe 64 calves were taken overnight from a farm in Mercer County, Ohio. The 13-week-old Holsteins were gone by morning, with authorities indicating the suspect was familiar with livestock handling.
people.com“Two different stages of cattle in that barn, again, which leads you to believe that somebody directly involved in this industry is involved somehow.”
www.wsoctv.comMercer County Sheriff investigates the theft of 64 Holstein calves worth up to $128K. Officials warn of a potential black market amid record cattle prices.
www.farmanddairy.comCELINA, Ohio (WKEF) -- Authorities in Mercer County continue their investigation into a bizarre case of cattle rustling.64 calves were stolen from an area farm
dayton247now.comMany of the animals are described as having docked tails.
www.eagledayton.com